If you want to see what all of these edits look like combined, see this.) You can read below about my truncations of the conversations between the members of Bad Anon, between King Candy and Ralph, between Ralph and Vanellope, between Ralph and Felix, and between King Candy/Turbo and Vanellope. If such a reason indeed exists, I would genuinely appreciate it being shared with me.īest regards, allixpeeke ( talk) 17:10, 9 November 2014 (UTC) I made some further edits to this page, truncating the quotes greatly. But, perhaps there really is some valid reason said lyrics must remain absent from this article, some valid reason that I simply haven't yet realised. And the exchange between Vanellope von Schweetz and King Candy is almost entirely unnecessary (save, perhaps, for the last two lines thereof).Īll said and told, my inclusion of a few short lines from the soundtrack seems benign compared to the rather lengthy quotes included elsewhere in this article. Or consider the exchange between Wreck-It Ralph and Vanellope von Schweetz, which consists mostly of insults hurled by Vanellope at Ralph, and also meanders from thievery to a debate about the difference between coins and medals to insults to Ralph angrilly wrecking to more insults to some deal-making. For example, in the Dialogue section, there are some extremely long quotes that would be far better examples of copyright violations.Ĭonsider the long exchange between Wreck-It Ralph and King Candy, which meanders from Ralph being covered in sweets to a discussion of whether the throne room is pink or salmon to the question of whether Ralph is "going Turbo" to the point about Ralph wanting his medal back to King Candy's threat to throw Ralph into his fungeon (including a discussion on how fungeon is a play on words). Personally, it would seem to me that my edit was less of a copyright violation than many of the other edits that have been made to this article.
Perhaps this quote was deemed to be more of a copyright violation than the other quotes already on the page due to it consisting of lyrics, but that, too, wouldn't make sense when one considers that Wikiquote includes lyrics on many of its pages ( e.g., 1, 2, 3). I certainly abided by the Wikiquote:Limits_on_quotations#Films rule in that I did not add more than five quotes in a single hour-indeed, I only added two quotes total. What I'm not sure is why my edit constituted a greater copyright violation than any other quote from the film already listed. I can only assume that the revision's intended target was the song lyrics.) ( WikiLubber also removed my ultra-short Vanellope von Schweetz quote in the same edit, although I couldn't possibly imagine that WikiLubber removed that quote intentionally, given its brevity. Later that same day, WikiLubber removed my addition, writing merely "Removed for copyvio." You can see this reversion here. Further, the lyrics I included constitute a short back-story to the lead character in the film, and thus seemed wholly appropriate for inclusion. As you can see, I included only a small portion of the song. On 6 November, I added a short quote from the song "Wreck-It, Wreck-It Ralph," a song from the film. Motion to re-add a quote from the song "Wreck-It, Wreck-It Ralph" by Buckner & Garcia
6 I've truncated the discussion between Ralph and Felix.5 I've truncated the discussion between Ralph and Vanellope.4 I've truncated the discussion between King Candy and Ralph.3 I've truncated the discussion between the members of Bad Anon.1 Motion to re-add a quote from the song "Wreck-It, Wreck-It Ralph" by Buckner & Garcia.